Yes, the motherhood penalty is real

by
Jenna Vassallo
Jan 10, 2024
Frustrated person sits at a conference table

The motherhood penalty—the idea that moms are less competent and committed to work, which results in lower earnings and fewer opportunities for career advancement—is real.

This is problematic in many ways, but it’s not something we see public figures talk a ton about - until now. The tides are finally turning thanks to advocates like Paula Faris.

Yes, we’re talking about that Paula, former co-host of The View, anchor at Good Morning America and a general correspondent at ABC.

After years as an Emmy-winning journalist, the mom of three founded CARRY Media™, where she champions women in the workforce to transform the reality of working mothers.

We chatted with Paula about her transition out of TV to become a trusted resource for working mothers and some of the interesting topics she covered in her new book, You Don't Have to Carry It All: Ditch the Mom Guilt and Find a Better Way Forward.

Here are three highlights:

She got to the top—and then burned out and made a change

At the height of Paula’s career in 2018, it seemed like she had it all – but she was actually super burned out. She pumped the brakes to join ABC, where she had a more standard Monday through Friday schedule that allowed her to see her family. Then, right before the pandemic, she learned they weren’t renewing her contract.

“I really started realizing when I was working that motherhood is very marginalized in this country,” she said. “It was my own experience of just getting passed over on promotions and getting paid less, being valued less, being scrutinized more.”

Instead of continuing her career as a TV journalist, Paula and her family left New York City for South Carolina, where she formed CARRY Media™ to focus on advocacy work to ensure mothers feel well supported and valued in the workplace. She chose her company name because she wants to help carry the burdens of working moms.

The happiness gap that exists for U.S. working mothers

Paula talked to historians, sociologists, thought leaders, theologians and moms from all walks of life while writing her book to figure out what we can do as a society to support working moms and why it's important.

“I wanted this book to feel like a hug and a sword,” she said. “I wanted mothers to feel seen and heard, but I also wanted them to feel really empowered. And I wanted there to be some almost myth-busting, some context as to like, ‘Here's why it's so freaking hard.’”

One of her sources, Dr. Jennifer Glass, a University of Texas sociology professor and the executive director at the Council for Contemporary Families, conducted research that exposed a “happiness gap.” It means there is a substantial delta between the happiness of parents and non-parents because of the stress and the strain of raising children in this country.

“We don't have support from the policymakers,” Paula said. “We don't have support from society. We have a general attitude in this country of, ‘Your kid, your problem.’ It's not like that in other countries. So this happy gap is an American phenomenon.”

Spousal inequality is fairly new

Paula’s husband left his job – twice – to prioritize her career opportunities in other cities. She acknowledges that her story of spousal equity is the exception.

That's where she got into researching the historical perspective of marriage and partnerships. She found that the expectation that a man's job will be more important than a woman's is fairly new.

“The most traditional nuclear family wasn't that 1950s family,” Paula said. “It was the family that worked side-by-side, that labored and produced and parented together.”

While she thinks many families are still living with the generational weight of this outdated concept of gender roles, Paula thinks there’s much more equality today thanks to millennial dads and even Gen Zers.

“Spouses are becoming true partners,” she said. “So it's not like you do this, I do that. You're actually partnering in everything together.”

To celebrate all we’ve accomplished, our team shared what they’re most proud of since joining the team:

I'm most proud of how much we have done to improve the single hardest moment for women's careers (going on parental leave) ... one that is often shrouded in insecurity and fear. We've been able to help advocate for so many women (and men!) in a way that is empowering and truly life-changing.

Allison Whalen, CEO & Founder

What am I most proud of? Growth! Growing a category of support that didn't exist before Parentaly. Growing from a one-woman bootstrapped operation to a global team of 25+ employees and coaches. Growing our overall impact for working parents, with companies investing in our parental leave programming to support employees all over the world. And growing as humans: new babies, new friends, new life experiences... all while tackling new and exciting work challenges together.

Rich Burke, Head of Growth

When I reflect on what I am personally most proud of during my time here, it's working alongside a team where we constantly evolve and optimize everything that we do in order to deliver the best possible experience for the folks going through our programs. It sounds cheesy, but there are processes that my team and I used to do 100% manually that are now completely automated and systems in place that have become second nature to how we operate. Working with such thoughtful, smart, and creative people is incredible.

Sara Ophoff, Senior Program Manager

I’m most proud about doing work that makes parents feel confident and empowered about their careers during a time that can be overwhelming and challenging – not only for our clients and users who go through Parentaly’s programs, but also with our advocacy work on LinkedIn, through our podcast and other big campaigns that make a difference. It’s been pretty rewarding to build a brand people know and love because what we’re doing resonates with so many employees’ experiences in the workforce.

Jenna Vassallo, Head of Brand & Marketing

I am so proud of the way we've approached growth with such care and intentionality - with every adjustment we've made to our offerings, we've never lost sight of our goal to provide the most supportive and valuable experience for our users. I love looking back on the early stages of conversations and building that have led us to the experience we offer today. Personally, I am extremely proud of the work I've done to scale and automate our backend!

Rachel Andes, Program Associate

I am most proud of the work we do every single day to make a positive impact on working parents! Everyday I get to work with an amazing group of people…we work hard but we also have fun.

Sarah Gruber, Client Partner

I'm proud of scaling an employee experience that consistently delivers positive outcomes for new parents and their organizations. Our north star has always been the user, and we never sacrifice our high quality bar!

Mansi Kothari, VP of Product & Experience

I feel a sense of pride that I get to work behind the scenes supporting everyone. I’m proud to see all of the collaboration between the team and how Parentaly positively impacts employees.

Leo Manalo, Executive Assistant

I'm most proud of going through the Parentaly program myself! I'm so proud to work for and promote this company in a time where parental leave and supportive policies are at the forefront of a national conversation. But beyond this, I'm most proud to call myself a participant.

Emmy Carragher, Enterprise Partnerships

I’m really proud of the work I did to expand our coaching bench globally at Parentaly. It was so rewarding, not to mention insightful, to connect with talented coaches from around the globe. This expansion not only enriched our coaching offerings but also strengthened our commitment to making a meaningful impact on families all over the world.

Nicole Hagemann-Bex, Senior Coaching Operations Manager

I have tremendous pride in the knowledge that what I am doing will change the career landscape for new parents, particularly mothers. This will make it more likely that my daughter can have a career AND a family without worrying about the unintentional negative impact of taking parental leave. Nothing makes me prouder than that.

Mindy Himmel-Brown, Strategic Partnerships

In my short time at Parentaly, I'm proudest of the work we're doing with our clients' ERG groups to elevate the stories and advice of actual working parents. It's such an impactful way to spread the word about Parentaly as an essential resource for all people growing their families, and the managers who support them!

Alex Diskin, Enterprise Account Manager

I'm most proud about using LinkedIn to connect with others. I was recently able to share a helpful return to work doc with 50+ new people looking to make a difference at their company. Was pretty cool that people from Chewy, McDonald's, Honda, Cisco, AWS, Walmart and more want to integrate just a piece of what we have to offer. Also...I'm so proud of the way I feel as an employee at Parentaly. For the first time in my career my personal interests align with my professional interests and I've never felt more motivated.

Jenny Hurwitz, Strategic Partnerships

I'm really proud of being able to help the Experience team by handling the supportive functions so they can focus on the bigger picture. It feels great to know that I’m making things easier for them and contributing to the team’s success.

James Mango, Executive Assistant
Tagged
Gender equity
Podcast recap
Work discussion

Want to learn more about Paula’s advocacy around equity in the workforce for women and her new book?

Listen to the full episode of The False Tradeoff!